Family Health Legal Library

Marital Issues When Medical Problems Arise

Community Property States: Who Owns What?

Community property is property that is acquired after the date of the marriage by the joint work, sacrifice and stress of both you and your spouse. Each spouse owns one half of these assets, whether they are divided, divisible or not. This ownership interest defines what each spouse owns during the marriage.

Not all property acquired after marriage is community property. If one spouse receives a gift, or regular gifts, from their family members, for example, that property is the separate property of that spouse. The designation of this property as separate [whether it is "separate" or "community" is called the character of the property] can change in certain circumstances. If the gift is used to pay for food, shelter or other marital purposes benefiting the other spouse, this previously separate property may now become community property since it may be deemed to have been "donated" to the marital community. Please note that this is a generalization and there are many factors which make up the character of the property.

Also, property acquired before the marriage may be either community or separate property depending upon the use of the property after the marriage. As an example, if one spouse had $40,000 in Certificates of Deposit before a marriage and the Certificates were simply renewed and the proceeds reinvested, the Certificates might likely remain separate property. However, if the Certificates were used as collateral for a marital loan which was taken out to purchase furniture for the spouses' house, this can, in some instances, arguably, change the character of the property. Such a situation might be one that must be resolved by the court system.

Premarital agreements, often called prenuptial agreements in some states, can help to specify, before a marriage what the character of each piece of property owned by each spouse will be. While these agreements sometimes makes for nice neat resolutions of property disputes upon divorce, the idea of planning for divorce sometimes prevents couples from entering into these agreements. Also, what is often not discussed about a property settlement agreement is that once made, it can be modified by the conduct of the spouses or spouse during the marriage. An example may illustrate this point. Assume that a spouse has $100,000 in stocks before being married. The couple enters into a valid prenuptial agreement in which it is specified that the stocks are the separate property of the one spouse and any dividends or interest from these stocks will be reinvested and remain the separate property of the spouse also.

After five years of marriage, the spouse decides to stop the reinvestment of the dividends and interest and designates these to be deposited each month in the couple's checking account to be used to purchase food and shelter. This practice continues for five more years. What is the character of the stock now? What is the character of the dividends and interest now? First, the stock would likely remain the separate property of the spouse pursuant to the agreement. However, it is entirely possible that the other spouse could argue that the dividends and interest income became a community asset. The final determination would depend on other factors during the marriage, but it is possible that the prenuptial agreement could be considered to be modified by the subsequent conduct of the parties during the marriage.

These principles may serve as an introduction to the community property laws. Your state may not have these, but if it does, these principles might help you better understand the need to seek the services of an attorney both before and during a marriage should questions arise concerning the nature of property.

Our Hypothetical: What happens in a community property state if the husband is paralyzed in a car accident? In truth, nothing happens as to ownership of property in a marriage, so long as the parties remain married. There may be some steps the couple can take with respect to debts, including bankruptcy if necessary, but the character of property would not change.

Marital Issues When Medical Problems Arise
1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  
Sections Available in Family Health Legal Library
How to Use the Family Health Legal Library
Healthcare Directives: Preventing Serious Legal Proceedings
Durable Power of Attorney For Healthcare
Durable Power of Attorney
Considering a Life Care Plan
Protecting Your Estate
Wills
Revocable and Irrevocable Living Trusts
Medicare: Do You Know All You Should?
Medicaid - What If This System Is Necessary
Credit and Debt Problems with Medical Issues
Medical Surgeries, Diagnosis and Related Issues
Children at College Issues
Marital Issues When Medical Problems Arise
Introduction to Contract Issues
Specific Types of Contracts and Contract Issues
More Examples of Special Contracts
Real Estate Issues
Typical Consumer Problems

The Law
  in Your Life
Elder Care
Family Health
  Legal Library
Access Financial
Credit, Debt and Budgeting
Immigration
Small Claims &
  Consumer Help
Domestic Violence
Anatomy of a Case
Identity Theft
ID Theft Risk Calculator
Legal Document
  Library
  Speeding Tickets